Syria, Trump and isolationism - Vilas County News-Review
ABOUT ▼
MEET THE STAFF
ADVERTISE
CONTACT
SUBMISSIONS ▼
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
NEWS TIPS
PHOTO SUBMISSIONS
ANNIVERSARY ANNOUNCEMENT
ENGAGEMENT ANNOUNCEMENT
WEDDING ANNOUNCEMENT
OBITUARY POLICY
PHOTO GALLERY
LOGIN-OUT
GO
Search only accepts letters and numbers.
HOME
NEWS
LIFESTYLE ▼
Slices of Life
Conover-Land O' Lakes
Phelps
Sayner-St. Germain
Three Lakes
Community Calendar
OUTDOORS ▼
Fishing with the Guides
In the Outdoors
SPORTS ▼
Sports Sidelines
OPINION ▼
Will Maines
Byron McNutt
Robert Reich
Cal Thomas
PUBLIC RECORDS ▼
Births
Engagements
Obituaries
Weddings
CLASSIFIEDS ▼
News-Review Classifieds
North Woods Trader Classifieds
SUBSCRIBE
Syria, Trump and isolationism
By Cal Thomas
4/17/2018 11:14 AM
select
Delicious
Blogger
Digg
Reddit
StumbleUpon
MySpace
Tumblr
ShareOnYammer
Pinterest
GoogleBookmarks
ShareOnGooglePlus
Tell a friend
THE ISOLATIONIST SPIRIT, a reluctance to become involved in foreign entanglements, goes back in U.S. history to Thomas Paine and his 1776 pamphlet “Common Sense,” and to George Washington’s 1796 “Farewell Address.”
In modern times, the isolationist spirit had a strong pull against U.S. involvement in World War I and World War II, but was eventually overcome, however reluctantly, by catastrophic events.
Whether he realizes it or not, President Donald Trump tapped into that spirit when he instructed military commanders to wrap up America’s role in Syria and to bring the troops home within months. One can almost hear the echo of Sen. George McGovern (D-South Dakota), who said in reference to the U.S presence in Vietnam “Come home, America.”
Osama bin Laden bet on America’s impatience with protracted wars in devising his terrorism strategy, but if one side is in it to win it and the other establishes a timetable, as President Barack Obama did in Iraq, it isn’t difficult to predict which side will be victorious.
Writing in the Washington Free Beacon, Aaron Kliegman lists five reasons why the United States should not leave Syria. Trump should read and heed them.
First, wrote Kliegman, ISIS remains in Syria and continues to pose a threat, even though its ambition for a caliphate has been temporarily thwarted. People who believe they have a religious mandate to keep fighting, believing their reward is heaven should they die, will not be easily dissuaded by people they regard as occupiers and infidels.
Kliegman’s second reason for not abandoning Syria is rooted in the recent example cited above. When Obama announced the complete withdrawal of U.S. forces from Iraq in 2011, disaster ensued. First, there was sectarian warfare between Sunni and Shia Muslims, followed by the regrouping of al-Qaida in Iraq into Syria, which morphed into ISIS, requiring a stepped-up military presence ordered by Trump.
Reason three: A premature withdrawal would undermine the president’s Iran policy, which includes abandoning the nuclear deal with Iran, possibly as soon as next month. “It simply does not make sense to leave the nuclear deal, impose more sanctions and target the regime’s development and proliferation of missiles only to cede Syria to Iran,” wrote Kliegman.
Reason four: “Washington would further lose its ability to influence events, ceding control to hostile authoritarians.” While the Trump administration wants to pull out, the presidents of Russia, Iran and Turkey held a summit last week in Ankara, Turkey, on Syria’s future. Without an American presence, it isn’t difficult to predict Syria’s future. It will likely serve as a base for increased terrorism.
Reason five: The United States would abandon the Kurds to a violent fate. The Kurds in Syria, noted Kliegman “have by far been Washington’s most effective partner in fighting ISIS on the ground.” They also have faced fierce opposition from the Turkish government in northern Iraq. Abandoning allies is not a good way to build trust and confidence among friends in the ongoing war against terror.
I would add a sixth reason: the recent chemical weapons attack that killed dozens of civilians. A precipitous U.S. pullout would only encourage the Assad regime and their Russian supporters to continue this assault on international norms and treaties, and opponents of the government.
The Middle East is a mess and has been for some time. No one-size policy fits all circumstances, but premature withdrawal is not a policy. At least, not one that will lead to victory or, at a minimum, stability. Perhaps Trump can get our allies to share more of the cost and burden. For certain, cost and burden will be much greater if he follows in Obama’s footsteps and makes a decision that feels good at first, but in the end, exacts a much higher price.
Submit a comment
Please fill out the form below to submit a comment.
We welcome your comments at vcnewsreview.com. Comments will be limited to 5,000 characters. Persons commenting must provide their full name and email address. Anonymous comments will not be posted. Comments should remain on the topic set by the original article. Personal attacks, profanity, slander, libelous statements and texting language will not be allowed. All comments will be reviewed prior to posting. Comments will only be posted during regular business hours. Phone numbers are optional and will not be publicized.
Comment
Message is a required field.
Your Name
Email
Phone
Captcha entry is not valid, please try again.
A comment must be approved by our staff before it will be displayed on the website.
Submit
X
Download Our App!
Get notified on Breaking News!
Tweets by POTUS
SITE LINKS
AFFILIATES
AFFILIATES (CONT.)
USEFUL INFO
News
Lifestyle
Outdoors
Sports
Opinion
Public Records
Classifieds
Subscribe
More Lifestyles
The Ada Herald
Bolivar Bulletin Times
Dearborn County Register
Delphos Herald
Eagle Print
Falmouth Outlook
Iron County Reporter
Monroe County Beacon
Paulding Progress
Putnam County Sentinel
Ohio County News
Rising Sun Recorder
Star Gazette
The Harrison Press
The Journal Press
The Times Bulletin
Waushara Argus
Forms and Flyers
Mechanical Information
Media Kit
Rate Card
Preprint Distribution Rate Card
Letters/Comments Policy
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##
{1}
##LOC[OK]##
##LOC[Cancel]##